Top 5 Best Cartilage Hoop Earrings (2020 Review)

Looking for a good pair of cartilage hoop earrings

Perfect, you're in the right place! In this Learning Jewelry guide, you'll learn: 

  • What Are Cartilage Hoop Earrings?
  • Are Cartilage Hoop Earrings Expensive Or Cheap?
  • What Is The Best Metal For Cartilage Piercings?
  • Can You Sleep With Hoop Earrings? 
  • Where To Buy Cartilage Hoop Earrings?
top best cartilage hoop earrings reviewed

Initially inspired by rock die-hards and the pop culture, cartilage earrings have since found their way in today’s culture coming in various options. In this particular piece. We’ll focus on the hoop types and how they are popular in today’s fashion world. 

Sandwiched between edgy and delicate, these cartilage earrings have an interesting vibe to it, especially in terms of detail. 

From small little rings of gold, or silver, to colored resins, cartilage hoops have the best style designs, an indicator that the trend won’t be going anytime soon. That being said, here are my top 5 favorite cartilage hoop earrings (and money saving tips too). 

ImageProduct
digital-business-prep-table__image
14k Solid Gold Fire Opal Earring
  • High quality craftsmanship
  • Extra opal included
  • High quality craftsmanship
  • Extra opal included
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Titanium Hinged Sleeper Earrings
  • Hypoallergenic titanium
  • Great closure mechanism
  • Hypoallergenic titanium
  • Great closure mechanism
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Sugar Tang Hoop Earrings
  • Superb design
  • Simple packaging
  • Superb design
  • Simple packaging
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
10K Gold Open Hoop Earrings
  • Classy look
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Classy look
  • Hypoallergenic
View on Amazon
digital-business-prep-table__image
Small Sterling Silver Cartilage Hoop Earrings
  • Comes in 3 pairs
  • Simple appeal
  • Comes in 3 pairs
  • Simple appeal
View on Amazon

Our Overall #1 Rated Pick

(updated as of 12/23/2019)

  • High quality craftsmanship
  • Extra opal included
  • 14K Gold
  • Affordable

Our top pick for a cartilage hoop earring went to the 14k gold fire opal design.

Why?

Because this while it looks simple, the fire opal adds a striking uniqueness, at an affordable price point.

These hoops are available in 16 gauge and 18 gauge with a ring diameter of about 8 mm. It’s a perfect earring for any cartilage size and will definitely hold well. 

Apart from standing out themselves with the fire opal, the cartilage earring may blend well with other earring types without fighting for attention. It’s a nice gift for loved ones as well. I’m sure they’ll feel special! 

Top 5 Best Cartilage Hoop Earrings

What Are Cartilage Hoop Earrings?

These are earrings made to fit at the top part of your ear (cartilage). The hoops fit well with helix piercings, although you can also have them just above the earlobes.

Cartilage hoops are quite light and you’ll love them if you don’t like having heavy earrings hanging on your lobes. 

Since they are tiny, you can always mix and match them up during occasions like weddings, parties, and family meet-ups. Even though designers offer a wide variety of pieces, I’d prefer choosing the lighter ones for everyday wear.  

Are Cartilage Hoop Earrings Expensive Or Cheap?

Obviously, with most things in jewelry you can get a piece that cost $20 bucks made from 14K gold with synthetic gemstones, or you could opt for a piece lined with diamonds and pay $2,400, like the hoop earrings below with 2.00 carat weight (CTW).

If you’re looking for an everyday jewelry piece, you’ll find a plethora in the cartilage hoops section selling for less than $20. On the other hand, fancier, statement pieces will cost you a bunch and depending on the metal/gemstone, you’ll dig deeper for a single pair. 

All in all, smart shoppers know what they want, and as a rule of thumb always ask yourself, “Will I still like it in the next coming months?” Once you get to understand the value of what you're purchasing, finding the right price becomes an easy task

What Should You Look For In The Best Cartilage Hoop Earrings?

Shape

Even though hoops have a general shape, they come in different styles and designs. Go for thick hoops if you have more professional day-to-day things to do. Thinner cartilage hoops tend to work better casual settings and for larger body sizes.

Material

Like any other type of earring, you should be aware of the material used. The general range is 14K to 18K gold, rhodium plating, or 925 silver. Low grade materials may nickel, triggering allergies. 

Gemstone

If you want to go on the cheaper end, you'll be looking at synthetic stones. For example, in our top pick for this post we recommend checking out the simple opal earring hoop. The opal is synthetic, but if you wanted something more pricey (and natural), diamonds are always an option.

What Is The Best Metal For Cartilage Piercings?

Cartilage hoops are stylish and come in various shades of gold, silver, platinum, titanium, rhodium and more. While choosing the best metal for your style, it is best to consider durability and compatibility.

Obviously, gold is a softer metal and may be less durable than say titanium. And since most brass or stainless steel varieties are usually electroplated, the fancy color will most likely wear off over time. 

That said, sterling silver has probably best balance between style and class. It blends with most outfits and has an authentic feel whenever you have them on. However, if you’re willing to spend extra on metals that may last decades, gold and platinum are your best bet. even though not as precious, stainless steel is also a durable option if you're cutting down.

Can You Sleep With Hoop Earrings?

Assuming your earrings aren't too big and bulky, it should be okay for you to sleep with them on. I would watch out if you have long hair as the earring may get caught up in your hair or if the earring itself is large, you may risk bending them in the process. 

All in all, if you really want to sleep with your cartilage hoops on, then just make sure the metal is sturdy and your earring doesn’t have and points. 

Can You Put A Tragus Earring In Your Cartilage Piercing?

First off, we need to know what types of earrings are best in the tragus. Studs and barbells are the most popular kinds, while hoop-lovers may add a pair to their cartilage piercing. That said, if you were using hoops for your tragus you can use it in your cartilage, no problem. 

However, I’m not really convinced that it is safe to use labret studs in your cartilage since the mechanism of closing is a little different.

Straight barbells also have a different close mechanism, and if you choose to have them on the cartilage, things might get a little messy.

I’d say, as long as they're not hoops, always be careful when exchanging earrings between different ear parts.  Ear piercings are sensitive and sometimes a thicker metal may cause damage.

Where To Buy Cartilage Hoop Earrings? 

In general, a pair of decent hoop earrings can be found on Amazon for a decent price. Unless you're looking to drop a couple hundred dollars on more expensive stones in stores like Blue Nile or James Allen, I'd recommend sticking to Amazon for these, which is where our recommendations come from. Take a look.

Reviews of the Best Cartilage Hoop Earrings

However much it’s simulated, this fire opal still makes the cut as an eye-catcher.

They can be worn in any kind of event and most people will notice how easy it is to wear with a matching outfit. It is a perfect gift for your loved ones, especially during the holidays. 

Pros

  • High quality craftsmanship
  • Extra opal included

Cons

  • Synthetic opal may turn off gem lovers

This pair of ear hoops come in different sizes (6mm, 8mm, 10mm) and are a match made in heaven for teens!

They’re easy to open (or close) and have a nice comfortable feel whenever you have them on. Even though some may find them small, once they are on, be sure they’ll buff up your outfit. 

They are also good on sensitive ears since the piece is made of non-irritant G23 Titanium. If you’re not familiar, some metals may do more harm than good, so I’d highly recommend this set of hoops if you’re not ready for discoloration or allergic reactions. 

Pros

  • Hypoallergenic titanium
  • Great closure mechanism

Cons

  • Gold plating may wear off

There is more to the sweet nature of SugarTang; they have amazing products! I stumbled on this CZ huggie and every detail in it looks beautiful (esp on women!). Casted in 925 Sterling Silver, the piece has an orbital conch and a nice flowery design filled with CZ crystals. 

They are sparkly enough to light up the dark colored outfits, although you wouldn’t get that much attention if you’re an it girl.

However, they will compliment other pairs quite well, especially if you add a dash of gold somewhere in between. The Platinum plating wouldn't get off easily, so prepare to have them for a long time. 

Pros

  • Superb design
  • Simple packaging

Cons

  • Tiny for larger lobes

This pair shows probably one of the oldest designs in the history of earrings. No funny impressions or designs, just a classic loop ready to rock your outings. The 10k gold makes it less prone to wear although it may not be as hard as its 14k counterpart.  

These hoops are both nickel-free and hypoallergenic. 

It also goes without saying that they are quite comfortable and a breeze to use. They’ll be a perfect gift for anyone who doesn’t have these in their collection. 

Pros

  • Classy look
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • Needs extra care
  • Sometimes hard to close back

If you don’t like too much detail on your hoops, then you should grab one of these silver earrings.

They come in various sizes (all under 15mm), all made with nickel-free 925 sterling silver perfect for sensitive ears.

Pros

  • Comes in 3 pairs
  • Simple appeal
  • Nickel-free

Cons

  • Difficult closing mechanism

My #1 Top Pick: 14k Solid Gold Fire Opal Earring

This 14K solid gold earring stood out while narrowing down the best cartilage hoop earrings.

They look surprisingly simple but then the fire opal adds a striking uniqueness. The hoops are available in 16 gauge and 18 gauge with a ring diameter of about 8 mm.

It’s a perfect earring for any cartilage size and will definitely hold well. 

Apart from standing out themselves, the cartilage earring may blend well with other earring types without fighting for attention. It’s a nice gift for loved ones as well. I’m sure they’ll feel special! 

Leave a Comment

Other Jewelry Guides

Looking to learn more about jewelry? Check out these other helpful resources!