Top 5 Best Earrings For Babies & Toddlers (2019 Review)

Looking for the best earrings for your baby or toddler? Perfect!

In this Learning Jewelry.com guide, you can expect to learn the following:

  • Our #1 overall best earrings for babies and toddlers for 2019
  • What to look out for when selecting earrings for your child
  • Why children’s earrings are different from adult earrings
  • Why not all metals are created equal when it comes to children’s earrings

Let’s get into it!

Engagement Rings

Top 5 Best Earrings For Babies And Toddlers

Short on time? Check out our quick list of recommended earrings for babies and toddlers. If you want to know WHY I picked these, continue on reading! 🙂

  1. Poplar Cubic Zirconia Set 9 (best of the best)
  2. Presentski Sterling Silver Cute Mouse Pink Earrings
  3. Sterling Silver Unicorn Earrings
  4. 925 Sterling Silver Screwback Baby Girls Earrings
  5. Gold High Polished Shiny Ball Post Stud Screwback Earrings

What are earrings for babies and toddlers?

Earrings for babies and toddlers are noticeably smaller than adult earrings, and quite often have a visual appeal that are exclusively designed for children.

The chemical composition of these earrings is usually different from those created for adults, because most countries in the world have laws that regulate the amount of toxic metals such as lead, nickel or cobalt that can be used in children’s earrings.

For example, the Canadian government restricts the amount of toxic metals such as lead and cobalt that can be used in earrings designed for children under the age of 15, whereas the same restrictions do not apply to adults.

In the USA, the federal government does not restrict the amount of nickel that is used in jewelry, but if products are advertised as ‘nickel-free’ then by law, they must have been tested.

Some states such as California, do have restrictions on the type of metals that can be used in jewelry, particularly those that are meant for children.

High quality children’s earrings are made from sterling silver, gold or surgical steel, and these metals are non-toxic, comfortable for most children and long-lasting.

Low quality children’s earrings will be made from flimsy materials such as plastic.

They may also include traces of nickel or lead, which are known to irritate sensitive skin, according to research from the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry.

Other qualities that are exclusive to children’s earrings include:

  • Shorter posts which do not poke the earlobes of young children who have smaller ears
  • The clasp that holds the earring in place is often smaller and tighter than adult earrings
  • This means you do not have to worry about the earring falling out when the child is playing or running.

The screws on the backs of the earrings are very unique. They tend to be smoother on the bottom and have a tighter fit.

This makes them more comfortable for children to wear and makes them less of a choking hazard.

Popular earrings for children include those shaped like Disney characters, birthstone earrings, which are crystals that are widely thought to represent the months of the year and bright, colorful earrings shaped like animals or cartoon characters.

Lab Created Diamonds

How to pick the best earrings for babies and toddlers

When selecting the best earrings for babies and toddlers, there are several things you need to consider, such as the metal, quality, size and style. We look at each of these in further detail below.

High quality metals vs low-quality metals

To find the best earrings for babies and toddlers, pay close attention to the materials.

Babies have undeveloped immune systems that make them particularly sensitive to nickel and cobalt.

The best materials to choose, according to Indiana University Health, are ones made from materials that do not irritate the skin such as sterling silver or 14- or 18- or 24-karat gold.

Another safe metal is surgical stainless steel, which is hygienic and durable.  

On the other hand, metals such as nickel and cobalt can cause conditions such as dermatitis. According to the Dermnet NZ medical website, one of the most common sites of jewelry allergy are the earlobes.

Therefore, when selecting earrings for babies and toddlers, be sure to avoid nickel and instead opt for high-quality metals such as sterling or silver.

If you cannot afford sterling silver or gold, surgical steel or platinum are affordable alternatives.

Size

Choosing earrings for babies and toddlers is not as straightforward as simply selecting the smallest size.

If you pick the wrong size for your child, it will either look too big and bulky for their earlobes, fall off, or cause discomfort.

There is obviously a big difference between a one-year old baby’s earlobes and a 3 year-old child’s earlobes, so age and earlobe size are important considerations when you are buying earrings made from precious gemstones and crystals.

Earrings made from precious gemstones are naturally heavier than other types of earrings, which will be fine for an older toddler but may be impractical for a baby, so keep this in mind when you buy jewelry for your child.

Choosing the right size means your child will be less likely to pull out the earrings or tamper with them.

Style

The style you should choose is mostly a matter of personal taste. In some ways, your choice could be based upon the personality of your son or daughter.

For example, if you have a lively child that loves the color blue, consider buying them some bright, blue earrings that represent their bubbly nature.

If the earrings are for a special event such as a wedding, then investing in a more expensive pair of earrings that are only worn for rare occasions may be worthwhile.

However, if you are buying earrings for a baby as opposed to a toddler, hoop earrings or bulky earrings are not recommended, so you should instead opt for studs.

This is because hoop earrings are too heavy for a baby and can cause serious injury if they get caught on something.

How to test for nickel

Signs of nickel allergy include rashes and irritation, according to healthcare experts at the Mayo Clinic, so it is important to ensure earrings do not contain this before you buy them.

Unfortunately, there is no reliable way to tell whether a pair of earrings contains nickel simply by looking at them.

However, many jewelry vendors will list the metals that are used to make the earrings.

High-quality earrings are usually advertised as nickel-free, so be on the lookout for this before purchasing.

There are also many commercial chemical products on the market such as Nickel Alert and Nickel Solution, which can help you to detect nickel in existing jewelry.

You can test for nickel by putting a few drops of these liquids onto a swab and rubbing it against the earring. If the colour of the swab turns red or pink, it is an indication that the earrings contain nickel.

How are earrings for babies and toddlers different from other pieces of jewelry?

This section looks at how earrings for babies and toddlers are different from older children and adults.

Naturally, children’s earlobes are smaller than adults, so this is why they are designed to have shorter posts and tighter clasps.

However, there are also a few key differences between earrings designed for babies and those designed for toddlers.

Earrings for babies and toddlers are designed to be extremely light – almost weightless, compared to those used by older children and adults.

How earrings for babies are different from any other type of earring

  • Earrings for babies are typically between 3mm-4mm, so they are an ideal fit for very young children with newly pierced ears
  • They are also made from very light and thin cuts of metals to avoid being too heavy for sensitive and fragile ears
  • High-quality baby earrings have very smooth and small screw back covers instead of butterflies so there is no risk of the earring post coming into contact with the baby’s earlobes
  • Most earrings for babies are designed to be flat studs as opposed to hoops.
  • This significantly reduces the risk of injury resulting from babies pulling on the earrings
  • Baby earrings must not contain any traces of nickel, lead or cobalt, because even trace amounts of these metals can cause irritation to a baby’s ears

How are earrings for toddlers different from any other earrings?

  • Toddler earrings can measure anywhere between 3mm and 5mm, which is smaller than those designed for adults and older children
  • However, they can also be slightly larger than those designed for babies
  • These earrings are made from thin metals so they are not too heavy for the child’s ears. They can sometimes be slightly thicker than those created for babies
  • The designs of toddler earrings can be either studs or very small hoops
  • Medium sized earring hoops are suitable for older children over the age of 4, but not for younger toddlers
  • Like babies earrings, those designed for toddlers must not contain toxic metals such as nickel or cobalt
  • Toddler earrings can have either butterflies or screw back covers.
  • However these are designed to be much smaller than those used by adults and older children, so they do not rub against the toddler’s ears

Where can I buy the best earrings for babies and toddlers?

Reputation, quality and value for money are important considerations when it comes to choosing a vendor to buy earrings from.

You’ll find plenty of stores online that claim to sell the best earrings for babies and toddlers and it can be a little overwhelming for parents who are hunting for the best deal.

This is one of the reasons we recommend Amazon, which is really a collection of stores.

Why Amazon?

Amazon makes it easy to scan through scores of vendors and jewelry stores, which you can then quickly filter in terms of reviews, price and quality.

You’ll also find many jewelry stores that sell earrings that are exclusively designed for children in terms of size, design and style.

The other great advantage of Amazon is that the products are almost always shipped very quickly compared to many other online retailers, usually within 3-5 days.

Many of the earrings for babies and toddlers sold by vendors on Amazon are advertised as nickel-free, so you don’t have to worry about toxic metals irritating your child’s skin.

Amazon also has one of the most flexible and straightforward refund policies online, and products can be returned within 30 days, regardless of the individual policies of vendors.

Product Reviews

Presentski Sterling Silver Cute Mouse Pink Earrings

These earrings are made from high-quality sterling silver and cubic zirconia.

They come in two different colors: pink and blue.

The size and design of the earrings makes them ideal for toddlers. They also come with a small butterfly to secure them in place.

Pros

  • The earrings are free from nickel so they do not cause allergies
  • The earrings are perfect for young Disney fans due to the Mickey Mouse design, which will appeal to many children
  • The earrings are presented in an attractive jewelry box, which makes them an ideal gift for family and friends

Cons

  • The long stem of the earring may be uncomfortable for a younger child, so this means they are more suitable for toddlers, rather than babies
  • The earrings are a little heavy, so they can be uncomfortable for some children
  • The earrings need to be frequently cleaned according to the product description, so they may be difficult to maintain

Sterling Silver Unicorn Earrings

These beautiful unicorn shaped earrings are designed exclusively for young babies and toddlers.

They are made from 925 sterling silver and come complete with small studs and earring posts that are perfect for children and babies that have recently had their ears pierced.

Pros

  • Made of high-quality sterling silver that does not cause irritation to children
  • The unicorn design has a universal appeal to most children
  • The earrings come in a variety of different colors so you can select the style that match the personality of your child

Cons

  • There have been complaints that the earring stems have come loose
  • The earrings are extremely delicate and easily damaged by chemicals and abrasions
  • The seller does not provide product dimensions, which makes it hard to decide how well they will fit your child

High Polished Shiny Ball Post Stud Screwback Earrings

These classic and minimalist earrings are ideal for everyday use.

They also come complete with a screw back mechanism that secures them in place. The smallest earrings come in a size of 4mm, which means they are small enough for babies and toddlers.

They are made from solid gold and are nickel-free.

Pros

  • These earrings come with a branded MASSETTE certificate so you know that these are the real deal
  • These earrings are made from solid gold and are not plated, which increases their value and quality

Cons

  • There have been complaints that the back of the earrings do not stay in place
  • The earrings may be a little too long for some children which increases the risk of the earrings poking the earlobes
  • There have also been complaints that the earrings break easily

925 Sterling Silver Rhodium Cross Cubic Zirconia Screwback Baby Girls Earrings

These stylish silver plated earrings are made of 92.5% sterling silver and add a little bit of sparkle to your child’s outfit.

There are no toxic materials such as nickel and lead, so they do not irritate your baby’s skin.

They come complete with screw backs, which securely locks the earrings in place, and prevents any poking of the earlobe.

Unlike many similar sterling silver earrings on the market, the Poplar Cubic Zirconia Set does not get damaged when exposed to the elements.

This means that you never have to worry about buying a new pair of earrings every time your child goes out in the wind and rain.

The earrings come in the following 3 sizes: 4mm, 5mm and 6mm, so you can choose the one that suits you the most.

Last but not least – the earrings are an affordable alternative to diamonds, and its high quality cut combined with that added sparkle will make your child will look like royalty.

Pros

  • The earrings are made from high-quality metals that do not rust or diminish with time
  • The sparkly and shiny nature of the earrings will look adorable on any child
  • The screw back increases comfort because there is no needle to poke the earlobes

Cons

  • The small size of the screw back makes it difficult and awkward to insert the earring back onto the earlobe
  • There have been complaints that the wire that holds the cross onto the rest of the earring have come loose
  • At 6mm x 8mm, the earrings are suitable for toddlers but not babies

Poplar Cubic Zirconia set

Out of the products we reviewed, our top pick goes to the Poplar Cubic Zirconia Set.

They come with both spare silicon backs and plastic backs, which will come in handy if you lose the metal butterflies.

The stud earrings are secured by a butterfly that is easy to secure.

Pros

  • Earrings are made up of ultra-high quality 925 sterling silver that is long lasting, comfortable and ideal for sensitive skin
  • The 3 different sizes make them ideal for both babies and toddlers, which means you can save money
  • They come with extra plastic backs that will come in handy if you lose them!

Cons

  • There have been reports that the backs of the earrings bend easily
  • The plastic backs can be a little awkward to screw on
  • Earring posts have a tendency to break if you get the wrong size
JamesAllen Engagement Rings

My Top Pick: Poplar Cubic Zirconia set

The Poplar Cubic Zirconia set is the clear winner.

Why did it make the cut?

I loved them for the following reasons:

1)   Nickel free

  • Nickel is widely known to cause allergies. These earrings do not contain it.

2) Comfortable

  • The earrings are made from thin cuts of high-quality metals, which will not be too heavy for children of any age

3) Safe

  • The flat design of the studs significantly reduces the risk of children pulling out the earrings. The plastic screw back covers ensure the posts do not rub against the skin of small babies and children

4) Stunning

  • The zirconia gemstones really do look like diamonds, but without the hefty price tag. The quality is great too so you never have to worry about the gemstone coming loose

5) Quality

  • The sterling silver combined with the platinum plating ensures that the earrings maintain their appearance even when exposed to poor weather conditions

Other Jewelry Guides

Looking to learn more about jewelry? Check out these other helpful resources!

Leave a Comment