Top 7 Best Online Stores For Diamond Earrings (2020 Review)

Looking for the perfect pair of diamond earrings online?

Here's a list of the top places you can trust to find stunning diamond earrings.

I'll also answer some common questions about buying diamond online, such as:

  • Where Can You Buy The Best Diamond Earrings Online?
  • Are Diamond Earrings More Expensive Online?
  • How Do You Know You're Getting A Good Deal?
  • What Are Some Red Flags To Watch Out For?
top best online diamond earrings review

Earrings are one of the most personal pieces of diamond jewelry you can buy from a jewelry store. With so many different styles, settings, and stones, your choice in earrings can be an outward representation of the inward you. 

When you buy diamond stud earrings at an online store, you are not simply just getting a random piece of jewelry.

With the online jewelers on this, you can pick out your loose diamond pairs and have them set. Instead of having to pick out something a store put together, you can be the designer. 

So, without further ado, let's get into it.

Top 7 Places to Buy Diamond Earrings Online

If you need the list quick, here are my top 7 picks for finding quality, reputable diamond earrings online. Keep reading for more information about each of these shops.

  1. James Allen (our top overall pick)
  2. Clean Origin (best for lab diamonds earrings)
  3. Blue Nile (best selection of earrings)
  4. Whiteflash (best earring cuts)
  5. Brian Gavin (best value of warranty + diamonds)
  6. Leibish and Co (best fancy colored diamonds)
  7. Abe Mor (best place to sell diamonds)

Buying Diamond Earrings At James Allen

james allen online diamond earrings store

James Allen is probably the leading online diamond retailer when it comes to purchasing all diamond jewelry. They offer the biggest selection in both loose diamonds and gemstones.

When it comes to diamond stud earrings, James Allen has you covered. 

You can customize the sliders to adjust the carat weight, color, and clarity grades. Additionally, you can select what type of cut as well.

I will say they have plenty of excellent and ideal cut diamonds as well, which is pertinent to diamond quality. 

James Allen offers you another type of cut in their selection, called True Hearts. True Hearts is their version of hearts and arrows diamonds, allowing you to see the symmetry and proportions from above the diamond.

To see high quality symmetry, you can view the pattern by looking through a jewelry loupe or microscope.

dangle diamond earrings from james allen
stud diamond earrings from james allen

This online diamond store offers GIA certified diamonds, so you know you're getting the best of the best.

James Allen also offers you a lifetime warranty where all routine metal work is done for free. Some of those include prong tightening, polishing, rhodium plating, and deep cleaning.

You can either send it to James Allen, or one their participating Jared retailers. 

Read Also: Insurance options with James Allen jewelry?

Now, if you're wanting to purchase fashion earrings instead of high quality diamond studs, I have to say that James Allen does not have the latest and greatest in diamond fashion earrings.

Upon checking out the different styles, I can say that the selection will only appeal to particular tastes, rather than a trendy look. 

Click here for our full James Allen review.

Pros

  • 360 view of loose stones
  • GIA certified
  • 24/7 customer service
  • 30 day returns
  • Lifetime warranty

Cons

  • Lacks in diamond fashion earrings
  • No trending styles

Buying Diamond Earrings At Clean Origin

Clean Origin is the leading online diamond retailer when it comes to selling lab diamonds. If you're not familiar, lab diamonds are diamonds just man-made in a lab.

Lab diamonds can be 20-30% cheaper than their natural counterparts and are 100% ethical given they are made in a lab and not mined out of the ground.

When it comes to diamond stud earrings, Clean Origin has an entire line of lab diamond earrings, which can save you a TON of money and still give you all the fire and scintillation you'd get from a real diamond.

With Clean Origin, they offer 3/4 CT to 2 CT weights at 14kt white and yellow gold settings.

The specs you can expect with Clean Origin are SI/VS1 for clarity and I/J for color ranges (near colorless).

Just to show you the price differential between James Allen's diamond studs and Clean Origin's diamond studs, below you can see James Allen's studs are nearly 2x the price for similar specs!

james allen vs clean origin studs

If you want natural diamonds I love James Allen's selection and pricing, but if you're okay with buying lab grown diamond studs online, then I really like Clean Origin.

They certify their diamonds with IGI, which isn't our favorite certifying body as they've had integrity issues. Personally, I recommend GIA or AGA certified diamonds only, but with lab diamonds the certification process is a bit different.

In fact, both James Allen and Clean Origin use IGI to certify their lab diamonds, so I wouldn't be too worried here.

Really, the only downside with Clean Origin, is they don't have a TON of selection when it comes to buying diamond stud earrings.

Just white or yellow 14kt gold settings, 3 or 4 prong set and 8 different carat weights. That's it. 

So if you just want a decent pair of stud earrings at the lowest price with minimal customization, then I recommend Clean Origin.

Click here for our full Clean Origin review.

Pros

  • 20-50% Cheaper Than James Allen or Blue Nile
  • 100 Day Return Policy
  • 24/7 customer service
  • High quality product

Cons

  • Not a lot of selection

Buying Diamond Earrings At Blue Nile

blue nile online diamond earrings store

When you buy diamond earrings with Blue Nile, I know you're picking from the best.

While other retailers in our top 5 have top quality loose diamonds, Blue Nile is my favorite place to buy diamond earrings from because no other retailer compares to their selections. Not only do they offer high quality studs built from loose stones, they have a killer section of diamond fashion earrings as well. 

Like all the other retailers, Blue Nile offers a section where you can build your own diamond earrings and pick out the specific qualities of the diamonds using filters.

Their Astor Collection is their own branded collection that has been certified by the GIA and has better brilliance than your average diamond and you can get Astor diamonds in earrings as well. 

diamond earrings from blue nile

Astor diamonds come with an additional Gemex Light certification specializing in the brilliance of diamonds. 

I really like how their options differ from most of the other guys on the list. Most of the build-your-own earrings are limited to the round diamond and sometimes the princess cut, but Blue Nile has added the Asscher cut as an option.

Nobody else on our list offers that. Additionally, you can also opt for build your own gemstone studs too, which no one else has either. 

What I don't like is that you can't look at both diamonds from the pair you pick out. I try to switch between the two, but the 360 view does not change.

You don't get to see the exact diamond characteristics like you can with others on our list. But that may not bother everyone.

diamond earrings from blue nile

Blue Nile gives their customers a lifetime warranty, but it only actually covers manufacturing defects. Normal wear and tear issues like prongs or polishing do not fall under this "warranty."

Read Also: Does Blue Nile offer discounts?

They do offer 30 day returns and the return shipping is free. They also have 24/7 customer service and a special line for military customers. 

Click here for our full Blue Nile review.

Pros

  • Wide selection of diamond earrings
  • 24/7 customer service
  • Asscher cut option
  • Free returns
  • Gemex certification with Astor
  • GIA certified

Cons

  • Warranty could be better
  • Can't see characteristics of both stones

Buying Diamonds At White Flash

white flash online diamond earrings store

whiteflash.com

White Flash is another great online jeweler in the realm of loose stones and diamond jewelry. Their collection of diamond fashion earrings is one of my favorites.

They have some really beautiful and unique pieces, as well as name brands like Ritani and Simon & Co.  

Looking through the collection, there are a lot of styles I haven't seen at any of the other competitors. Check out these earrings below from White Flash to see what I mean.

unique diamond earring style from white flash

https://www.whiteflash.com/diamond-earrings/star-cluster-diamond-earrings-by-zydo-30.htm

What's even more exciting about White Flash and their diamond earrings is their prices.

The prices are more affordable than most of the guys on this list. White Flash allows you to select diamond pairs based on filters as well.

They also have a patented collection called A Cut Above. This collection has four sub-collections, including a hearts and arrows with perfect optical symmetry. 

They offer a 360 view of your diamond pairs and even include additional ASET and ideal scope imaging of the hearts and arrows under a gemscope. I don't like the way they let you view the stones though.

The diamonds are put under a special light to make them sparkle against a black background, making it very difficult to see the diamond characteristics in any grade. But if that doesn't bother you, then don't worry it. 

White Flash offers you a one year free service guarantee, where you can get normal wear repairs done through them for free.

They also will do 100% trade-ins, 30 day warranties, and custom diamond jewelry. However, there are certain items from the virtual collection that have a 10 day return policy, so keep an eye out for that. 

stud diamond earring style from white flash

Pros

  • Affordable prices
  • Unique designs
  • Brand collections
  • Custom jewelry

Cons

  • Bad diamond lighting for viewing characteristics
  • No gemstone jewelry (or loose stones)



Buying Diamonds At Brian Gavin

Diamond earrings at Brian Gavin are both beautiful and beautifully priced. This is another affordable online diamond retailer.

There is a fair selection of diamond fashion earrings, though it looks like most of them are diamond hoops.

I do like that they carry diamond earring jackets as well, which allows you to fit over a pair of studs. And of course I have to show you these gorgeous gemstone/diamond hybrid earrings. Simply dazzling. 

unique flower diamond earring style from brian gavin

https://www.briangavindiamonds.com/diamond-jewelry/diamond-earrings/fashion/yellow-petals-18k-yellow-gold-4952y18

Out of all of the ways to view loose diamond characteristics, Brian Gavin has the best viewing filters.

Initially, you can slide the camera around the diamond to view it, which is something I don't like. But, when you click on the additional imaging videos, it allows you to segment angles of the diamond by repeating the same motion, allowing you to really get a look for any inclusions. 

When you look at the earring builder, I really like that they offer a bunch of different settings besides the classic prongs, scalloped basket, or martini look. Instead, you can select the diamond for unique settings, which I think is really cool.

Read Also: Best settings for diamond studs?

The earring diamond pairs come in four different shapes: round, princess, cushion, and emerald. 

Brian Gavin offers their customers one free resizing if needed, but all other repairs are chargeable. 

martini cocktail earrings diamond earring style from brian gavin

https://www.briangavindiamonds.com/diamond-jewelry/diamond-earrings/studs/martini-cocktail-earrings-5430

They offer a "lifetime warranty", but it only actually covers manufacturing defects. They also offer both a lifetime trade up and a buy-back program within the first year, but it is only on their signature collections. 

Pros

  • Best 360 viewer
  • Fair prices
  • Unique settings
  • Free resizing

Cons

  • Dismal lifetime warranty
  • No trade in for diamond jewelry



Buying Diamond Earrings At Leibish & Co

leibish online diamond earrings store

https://www.leibish.com/

When you buy diamond earrings from Leibish & Co, you are purchasing top quality unique diamond jewelry. This online retailer specializes in fancy color diamond earrings, unlike any of the other ones on the list.

Similarly, they also have the Asscher cut earrings, but only in the colored section. 

stud earrings diamond earring style from leibish

https://www.leibish.com/earrings-jewelry/round-brilliant-gia-diamond-halo-earrings-28819

Leibish & Co doesn't have many sets of colorless diamond earrings. But, if you are looking to brighten your ears with a pop of color or draw attention, this is the store for you.

The fancy colored diamonds are gorgeous, and they cost a pretty penny as well. You will pay over $500 for a setting of any kind in addition to the stone when you design your own earrings. 

In addition to the unique colors, the colored diamond earrings come in all sorts of diamond shapes. I mentioned before that most only carry round customizable diamond pairs, but Leibish and Co. colored diamonds offer many diamond shapes.

Some of the different options include radiant, trapezoid, triangle, and marquise

They do offer a no-questions-asked money back guarantee with the shipping label already paid for, so that's good. Lastly, they have a nice lifetime warranty where normal wear repairs are done for free. 

fancy rose gold diamond earrings from leibish online

https://www.leibish.com/earrings-jewelry/18k-white-and-rose-gold-fancy-brown-drop-halo-earrings-17110

Pros

  • Best colored diamond earrings
  • Top of line quality
  • More shapes
  • Lifetime warranty covers normal wear

Cons

  • Dismal collection of colorless diamonds
  • High in price




Buying Diamonds At Abe Mor

abe mor online diamond earrings store

https://www.abemor.com/

Abe Mor is an diamond wholesale company geared toward retailers and family owned jewelers rather than commercial customers.

It is a supplier, not an actual jewelry store. However, individuals can purchase Abe Mor diamonds and sell with them too. 

diamond stud earrings from abe more

https://www.abemor.com/view/4-prong-old-euro-diamond-stud-earrings-nyc/110

Abe More has a beautiful selection of diamond earrings, but you'll have to inquire within for prices. Because these pieces are geared for retailers, the loose diamonds and diamond jewelry are very expensive and unaffordable for most.

However, if you can afford it, they are well worth it.

Abe Mor specializes in the finest jewelry and can obtain rare or unique pieces from diamond sources that most retailers don't. Additionally, they do not offer repairs or warranties. 

pear shape diamond earrings from abe mor

https://www.abemor.com/view/pear-shape-halo-diamond-dangling-earrings-nyc/126

Abe Mor is great at being able to sell your diamond jewelry from home. They offer the most money out of diamond buying and will even sell it for you and send you your commission.

Or, you can sell your diamond and they work behind the scenes for you. This is their partnership program. 

Pros

  • Great place to sell diamonds
  • Unique sourcing (still conflict-free)
  • High end jewelry

Cons

  • No warranties
  • Expensive
  • No prices displayed
  • No pictures of loose stones

FAQ When Buying Diamonds Online

There are too many pairs of earrings on the web to count. And there are a lot of questions to ask.

Should you get a pair that's all diamonds or a mix of gemstones and diamonds?

What will you set it in? Rose gold? White gold? Maybe yellow gold?

The possibilities are endless. Check out the most asked questions about buying diamonds online. 

Is It Cheaper To Buy Diamond Earrings Online?

While there are many factors that might increase or decrease diamond prices when it comes to earrings, the cost of diamond earrings online and in a retail store do differ. 

Because these online retailers specialize in loose diamonds and allow you to select your specifications, you're going to find that a pair of diamond stud earrings is more expensive online than at a brick and mortar store.

Read Also: Best options for fake diamond studs?

This is because most commercial jewelry stores have a pile of manufactured diamonds that are certified and already selected. 

Red Flags When Buying Diamond Earrings Online?

As with anything you buy online, it is good to take a few precautions. Check out a few concerns to keep an eye out for in your diamond earring hunt. 

1. Conflict-free diamonds 

If you've ever seen the movie Blood Diamond with Leonardo DiCaprio, you may be aware that in certain parts of the world, diamonds are used to fund civil wars.

Retailers wanted to make sure that consumers knew they were getting their diamonds from a legitimate source, rather than one that causes pain and violence to people. 

Thus, the Kimberley Process was created. This is the main way to ensure quality diamonds come from non-conflict countries or areas. Over 80 countries participate in the program and all diamonds that come through those market channels are ensured to be conflict-free.

2. Return Policy

When buying diamond earrings online, always look for a solid money back guarantee. All of the retailers on this list have a 360 degree viewer for the loose stones of custom diamond earrings, but the other earring styles don't necessarily have those viewing options.

Read Also: How to buy diamonds online?

The main reason for returning a piece of fine jewelry back to an online diamond vendor would be because you didn't like the quality or the way it looks.

Thankfully, most online places offer 30 day returns, though some will give you only as little as a week to return pieces. Checking out the return policy will help you steer clear from any scams. 

online diamond earrings

3. Materials

When shopping for diamond earrings online, not only do you want to make sure you're getting exactly what you viewed online, but you want to make sure the materials are high quality. Always read product descriptions thoroughly. 

Look for proper terminology when buying diamonds. When you read "14K gold", make sure it is solid gold, not plated. Many cheaper diamond rings and other jewelry pieces can be plated and the plating will eventually fade to reveal a cheaper metal. 

Watch out for the following words: diamond simulant, lab-created diamonds, and treated diamonds. Make sure you know what each of these are and if you're wanting them before purchasing. 

How To Get The Best Deal When Buying Diamonds Online?

Most people think that the best deal is the lowest price. When it comes to diamond earrings, diamond engagement rings, or any other diamond jewelry, this is not the case. The best deal is the one with the most benefits. 

Beyond the initial price of your earrings, think about the maintenance on them that they might require. Do your research.

Certain settings will keep your diamonds more secure, such as a bezel setting. Channel-set princess cut diamonds are also pretty secure. 

To get the best deal on diamond earrings, look for someone that offers a lifetime warranty. While some repairs are not covered by certain warranties, a lot of places will do a lot of the routine care that is regularly needed under warranties.  

Learn More About Jewelry

Want to learn more about jewelry? Check out these other helpful resources!

Leave a Comment