Best Places To Buy Morganite Rings: The Expert’s Top 4 Picks Plus Tips (2021)

Looking for the perfect place to morganite rings online?

You're in the right place! 

In this Learning Jewelry guide I'll answer common questions like:

  • What Should You Look For When Buying Morganite Rings Online?
  • Are Morganites Rings Good For An Engagement Ring?
  • How Do You Know You're Getting A Good Deal?
  • What Are The Red Flags To Watch Out For When Buying?
morganite jewelry

Top 4 Best Places To Buy Morganite Rings Online

If you need the list quick, here are my top picks for finding morganite rings from reputable online dealers. Keep reading for more information about each of these shops. 

1. Brilliant Earth

2 Helzberg

3.James Allen

4. Blue Nile 

What Is Morganite?

Morganite is a peachy pink colored gemstone that comes from the mineral family beryl. Beryl comes in a different range of color varieties, similar to tourmalines, sapphires, and topaz. Some you're more than likely familiar with.

Emeralds are the deep green variety of beryl and aquamarines is the lighter blue variety. There are also green and blue beryl, but the color hues are one of the ways you separate gemstones. 

When colorless beryl has impurities of manganese, it causes a salmon to pink colored gemstone. Most morganite has received heat treatment to enhance color. 

Morganite has become a sought-after choice for both engagement rings and fashion jewelry alike. 

Here are the best places to buy morganite rings online: 

#1 Buying Morganite Rings At Brilliant Earth

brilliant earth - loose morganite

Brilliant Earth is a popular online diamond retailer that prides themselves on going beyond the responsible sourcing put forth by the Kimberley Process. But we're not talking about their diamonds today. 

Brilliant Earth is the only one of our picks today that allows you to choose your own loose morganite to place in one of their ring settings. All of our retailers allow you to do so with diamonds and select gemstones, but not to customize morganite engagement rings.  They also carry pre-set morganite rings. 

They don't have a huge selection of stones, but that's to be expected. It's not as popular as other colored gemstones and it's not generally super expensive either. All of their morganites have been heat-treated. They have a controllable 360˚ video that allows you to spin the morganite to check out any clarity imperfections or blemishes. 

Brilliant Earth's loose morganites selection will vary. A week ago, when this article was written, they had 35 loose morganites in 5 different shapes. Today, they are carrying 8 loose round cut morganites. Already you can see how popular they are. They carry mainly peach and pink morganites. 

You have around 230 choices for engagement rings settings in various metal colors and styles. The ring settings are more expensive at Brilliant Earth than some of our other options, so it's nice you get the option to purchase the morganite by itself. 

There's no free warranty with Brilliant Earth's jewelry, except a manufacturer's warranty. It covers design defects. For maintenance options, you can buy the 3-year Extended Service Plan. The cost is based on a sliding scale. If you don't like your morganite engagement ring from Brilliant Earth, they have 30 day free returns.

Pros

  • Carries loose morganites
  • 250 Ring setting options
  • Preset and Build Your Own
  • Option for paid maintenance warranty

Cons

  • More expensive for higher quality

#2 Buying Morganite Rings At Helzberg

Helzberg isn't often at the top of our lists, but today it is. They have biggest selection of morganite rings of all of our retailers. They don't sell loose morganites like Brilliant Earth, but they have more options than Blue Nile and James Allen put together. 

Helzberg is similar to jewelry retailers like Jared and Zales, except they are family owned. Their prices for engagement rings and wedding bands are similar too. I don't recommend buying a bridal set with them, but their morganite collection is on point. 

Unlike everybody else, Helzberg's morganite rings also come in sterling silver, white gold, and even 10K rose gold, which is cheaper than 14K. 

Most of their morganite rings are from a popular ring setting designer, Zac Posen. Zac Posen also has a line of ring setting over at Blue Nile. These rings come with a premium price because of the designer, so they'll be a more expensive than the average morganite ring. 

Even though they have less than 15 morganite engagement rings, they have some of the most unique preset morganite rings I've seen. They look very vintage and regal. 

If you buy a morganite ring from Helzberg, you have the option to add a lifetime care plan. The cost of plan will depend on the cost of your item. For example, this white gold morganite ring below for $1,799 will have a Lifetime Care Plan that costs 179.99. 

If you don't care for the morganite ring you purchased from Helzberg, they offer 30 day free returns. 

Pros

  • Has white gold options
  • Special designer morganite rings
  • Offers paid maintenance warranty
  • has physical locations too

Cons

  • designer ring setting cost more
  • no loose morganites

#3 Buying Morganite Rings at James Allen

Morganite Rings

James Allen hovers at the top of our guides a lot, but today they're ranking a bit lower. The reason why is because they have a small selection of preset morganite jewelry.

Under their Gemstone drop-down tab, you'll go to their Gemstone Rings page and filter the stone to morganite. Unfortunately, all 20 come selected, so you have to manually de-select all of them. I'd just search Morganite Ring in the search box to save yourself some time. 

Their 16 piece collection of morganite rings only comes is 14K rose gold. You don't have a lot of choices and almost all of the ring styles are halo rings. They don't have a true solitaire either because all of their rings have small diamonds either in the halo or in the setting. 

James Allen doesn't let you pick your own morganite gemstone, but I like that they at least give you the specs on it, like how many diamonds and their quality. Places like Kay and Zales will only give your general specs like a minimum clarity and color. 

You can still view the preset pieces through a 360˚ viewer just like a regular ring setting at James Allen. Even if you're not for clarity imperfections, it can show you how the light hits the stone in that setting. The viewer is easy to use and controllable so you can see the setting in its entirety. 

James Allen gives a free lifetime warranty with all of their fine jewelry, including their morganite rings. The warranty covers routine maintenance like cleaning and polishing as well as tightening stones or retipping prongs. If you don't like your morganite ring from James Allen, they have a 30 day money back guarantee.

Pros

  • Gives you specific details
  • 360˚ view
  • Free lifetime maintenance warranty

Cons

  • no loose morganites
  • not much variation in ring styles
  • only offers rose gold settings

#4 Buying Morganite Rings At Blue Nile

morganite jewelry

Blue Nile is a popular online diamond retailer for diamond engagement rings and wedding bands. They were the first retailer to do loose diamonds online back in 1999. This gives them an excellent and trusted reputation among customers. 

Blue Nile also has small collection of morganite rings, even smaller than James Allen's. Under their Jewelry tab, you'll hit the Gemstone Rings on the drop down window. Then filter the morganite.

Currently, Blue Nile has 11 morganite rings. Like James Allen, they  all have diamond accents, so not solitaire ring settings here either. Only two of them don't have have a diamond halo. One of the two also features aquamarines. 

Morganite and Aquamarine Diamond Cathedral Ring

There aren't any yellow gold or white gold options either, just 14K rose gold and one 18K rose gold ring. They have no 360˚ viewing option for the morganite rings. The picture provided is quality. 

The prices of Blue Nile's morganite rings are a little more on the expensive side. They only carry 1 option below $1000 currently. All of their morganite jewelry is heat-treated. 

Like other retailers, Blue Nile doesn't offer a warranty with their jewelry. They have the manufacturer's warranty to cover defects, but nothing for wear and tear. If you buy a morganite ring from Blue Nile, you have 30 days return it if it's not your taste. 

Pros

  • High quality photos
  • Different styles and shapes
  • Lifetime upgrade
  • 100 day returns

Cons

  • No loose morganites
  • $1000+
  • No warranty
  • No white gold or yellow gold

Morganite Rings FAQ

Here's a list of some of the most popular questions asked about eternity rings. 

Is Morganite Good For An Engagement Ring?

Since morganite is the peachy-pink variety of beryl, it will have the same durability and scratch resistance as emeralds and aquamarines. Beryl hits a 7.5-8 on mineral scale of hardness (Moh scale). 

Mohscale

So what does this mean exactly for an owner of a morganite engagement ring?

Diamonds are considered the hardest mineral at a 10 on the Moh scale. But a lot of people think that hardness means breakability. That's not the case. Hardness is basically scratch resistance.

And we're not just talking about obvious scratching, like when you know you hit your ring on something. Dust and dirt particles in the air scratch the surface every day. Over time, if your stone doesn't have a high hardness rating, it will be probably need to be replaced down the road. Little scratches can make it appear cloudy. 

A 7.5-8 isn't bad for daily wear. It's not a 10, but still not too soft. It will be fine for daily wear, so long as you're not too hard on your hands. A protective ring setting like a bezel or flush setting would add extra protectionJust make sure to remove it before doing any activities or cleaning. 

Is It Cheaper To Buy Morganite Rings Online?

In general, a morganite stone isn't overly expensive. 

But are they cheaper in stores or online? 

It depends where you shop and what quality of stone you're getting. Places like Etsy will probably run you pretty cheap for morganites because a lot of them are lab created, not natural. 

The heart of the cost of a morganite ring is going to be the ring setting. If you're custom building your morganite engagement ring at Brilliant Earth, it's most definitely going to be more expensive than a preset lab created morganite ring plucked from the jewelry case over at Kay Jewelers. 

But then again, one of those gorgeous morganite rings from Brilliant Earth is probably going to be less than this annoyingly overpriced rose gold morganite with diamond baguette accents from Kay's Neil Lane Collection. 

In all honesty, you're going to find a mess of different prices online and in-store. The cheapest morganite rings will be online with many options under $100 at places like Etsy or Ebay. Just make sure to read descriptions carefully because many aren't actual morganite or solid gold. 

Additionally, most physical jewelry stores don't care morganite ring sets, mostly just diamond jewelry.  Most will only have a few options while you have more than enough options for morganite engagement rings. Morganite wedding rings are even less common. 

Are Morganite Rings More Expensive?

Like mentioned above, morganite gemstones aren't very expensive on your credit card. They do have a range however, based on different quality factors. On average, they run between $20-$300 per carat. 

Top quality morganite may be more expensive. 

Brilliant Earth's loose morganites run between $600-$1500. These are best quality and allows the customer to build their personal ring without paying actual labor costs. 

Morganites rise in price the larger the carat, but not a whole lot. Color has more of an impact on price in this case than carat size. For example, a vivid rose colored 1 carat morganite may cost the same amount as a paler 3 carat morganite. Like other gemstones, morganite is more costly in matching pairs for stud earrings. 

Don't be surprised if the price of morganites are starting to rise. It's only mined from a few countries, mainly Brazil and Madagascar. Small amounts of morganite has also been found in Afghanistan, China, Russia, some places in the US, and some place in Africa. 

It's a basic example of supply and demand. Morganite is in very high demand in 2021. Once the supply starts becoming more scarce, the prices will rise. 

Lab grown morganite is available, but it's less common in the retail world. They are much cheaper than natural morganite. 

The bulk of the price of a morganite ring will be its setting. The most popular metal is 14K rose gold. Every so often you might ring 18K or 10K rose gold, but it's less common. 

What To Look For When Buying Morganite Rings Online?

Here are the things to keep in mind when buying and wearing morganite rings. 

Cut and Carat

With a diamond engagement ring, the cut is the most important of the 4Cs. With a colored gemstones the cut isn't the most important. Instead of paying attention to finite dimensions, you'll really want to eyeball the shape of the stone and make sure everything looks even.

That's especially important when looking at elongated morganite stone rings like a radiant cut or an emerald cut. 

Morganites do need to be cut well. They are subject to pleochroism, which is when a gemstone can exhibit different colors at different angles. Alexandrite is another popular pleochroic gemstone these days.  

Morganites can be cut into all different shapes. They're most often seen as cushion cuts or emerald cuts. There are many fantasy cut morganites and custom cut morganite rings as well. These morganites will also be more expensive generally. 

Large morganite crystals can be found so it's not uncommon to see morganite in larger carat weights. Larger morganites are more desirable because they present better color. Smaller cut morganites look more pale. 

Color and Clarity

Peach morganites are the most common, but that's not the color that's high in demand these days. People are looking for pink or rose colored morganite, or ones with a pinkish purple hue rather than pale peach. These colors may more more expensive. Pink is the best color, then purple, then orange, and peach. 

Because morganites exhibit such a soft tone (around a 3 on a scale) , they are commonly heated to improve color. You can still have natural morganite, they're just not usually as striking unless it's a large stone with deeper color. 

Like aquamarines, morganite should also be eye-clean without coming at a high cost. In clarity grades, most morganite would be either VS or VVS clarity. They should be free of inclusions and blemishes at 10x magnification. 

If your morganite stone has obvious inclusions, it's not a quality stone. Morganite's light tones will make inclusions more apparent. 

If it has tiny minor inclusions, that's okay.

Red Flags When Buying Morganite Rings

Aside from keeping those quality factors above in check, there's not a whole lot to watch out for when buying morganites. 

Gemstone Simulants

The biggest thing I advise you to do when buying morganite rings online is to make sure you're reading the descriptions for the morganite ring you're looking at. 

When you search morganite online, you'll come up with a lot of simulated stones titled as morganite. It's especially common on sites like Amazon or Etsy because they're trying to keyword other stones. 

Morganite simulants can be any stone or material that is a similar color and being passed off as morganite. Most common simulants include cubic zirconia or glass. Cubic zirconia is a cheap man made stone that can be created in any color of the rainbow. 

A lot of people don't know that glass can be faceted to look like gemstone. Check out this video below: 


Watch out for Windowing

Windowing is what happens to a gemstone that isn't cut right. It's more likely to happen to step-cut shapes like an emerald cut stone or an Asscher cut stone. Instead of reflecting light, you're able to see through the stone like glass. 

Buy from a Retailer with a Good Reputation

To avoid getting fake morganite, you should read descriptions well, or buy from a recommended retailer. Look for a retailer that has lots of reviews. Always read the return policy and the process to make sure you can send it back if it's not your style. 

How To Get The Best Deal When Buying Morganite Rings Online?

How To Get The Best Deal When Buying Morganite Rings Online?

Here's a quick recap on how to get the best deal when buying morganite rings online: 

  • Buy from a retailer with a good reputation
  • Read ring descriptions
  • Remember morganites should be eye-clean
  • Make sure your morganite is cut evenly
  • Choose certified morganites from reliable labs
  • Read the retailer return policy AND return process

Meet Your Jewelry Expert

Learn More About Jewelry

Want to learn more about jewelry? Check out these other helpful resources written by our jewelry experts!

Leave a Comment