Your Best Places To Buy Pear Shaped Diamonds Online: Top 4 Picks In 2021

Looking for the perfect place to buy pear diamonds online?

You're in the right place! In this Learning Jewelry guide I'll answer common questions like:

  • What Should You Look For When Buying Pear Diamonds Online?
  • Are Pear Diamonds Good For An Engagement Ring?
  • How Do You Know You're Getting A Good Deal?
  • What Are The Red Flags To Watch Out For When Buying?
Pear Shaped Diamond

Top 4 Best Places to Buy Pear Diamonds Online

If you need the list quick, here are my top picks for finding pear shape diamonds from reputable online dealers. Keep reading for more information about each of these shops. 

1. James Allen

Blue Nile

3.Clean Origin

4. Ritani

#1 Buying Pear Diamonds At James Allen

James Allen gives customers a generous selection for a diamond shape that's not very common. Using diamond grades with min 1 carat, SI clarity, and H color, they offer around 2300 loose pear shaped diamonds. 

If you've read any of our other diamond shape guides, you might notice that James Allen frequently holds the number one spot. That's because they often have all the tools necessary to pick out the best shape for you and pear diamonds are no exception. 

All of the pear diamonds in their loose diamond inventory have excellent viewing quality by way of their crystal clear 360˚ viewer. It makes it super easy to identify large inclusions and watching out for the bowtie effect.

James Allen doesn't sort their pear diamonds into cut categories since fancy diamond shapes have no official cut grade. You'll have to pay attention to the diamond specifics, which can be seen by clicking the ellipses when you scroll through the inventory. 

All of their pear diamonds are certified mostly by the GIA or IGI. Make sure to only pick GIA certified diamonds. You can also filter the lab by using the diamond filters. For more info about certification, check out the FAQ at the bottom of the page. 

Recently, James Allen has added a feature that expands their engagement ring settings. If your selected setting has a rainbow ring emblem, you can further customize it using the Ring Studio. You can have a rose gold prong basket atop a yellow gold ring shank if you wanted.

solitaire engagement ring

James Allen has a wide range of pear diamonds for a variety of budgets with different diamond grades. Additionally, all of James Allen's customers get a free lifetime warranty with their rings that cover all the maintenance engagement rings and wedding bands need over time.

Most places either charge for this or don't offer a maintenance warranty at all. 

Read also>> Does James Allen have a good warranty?

Pros

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Free sizing for a year
  • Lifetime upgrade
  • Clear 360 view
  • Cons

    • Not many choices in diamond fine jewelry 
    • Does not cover loss of stones in settings

    #2 Buying Pear Diamonds At Blue Nile

    blue nile heirlooms

    Using the same diamond grades mentioned above, Blue Nile has about 1700 loose pear diamonds in their inventory. 

    However, unlike James Allen, they don't have 360˚ viewing on every diamond. You'll want to go ahead and filter out the loose diamond inventory by checking 360˚ view. Doing that, we have narrowed down to just shy of 1300. Remember you can always expand these grades, we're just using them as an example. 

    The viewer at Blue Nile is pretty good. It always takes me a second to get it to run smoothly, but I just wish I could see it in higher magnification. I am very happy that I can control the rotation as well, because it makes it easier to test light performance

    I also love that all Blue Nile's diamonds are GIA certified. That definitely makes it easier on someone who might not know much about grading reports or why they're important. They don't have to worry about purchasing a diamond from a less reliable lab and get it straight from the world's leading resource in diamond quality. 

    For this reason, Blue Nile's pear diamonds might fetch higher diamond prices. They also separate their pear cuts into two categories, Good and Very Good. The Very Good pear diamonds will have more desirable and recommended proportions for that shape. 

    You'll also have more options with less glaring bowties because they will have better cut. You shouldn't choose from the Good cut category. 

    The one thing I can't forgive Blue Nile for is their lack of a warranty. Their lifetime manufacturer's warranty covers design defects in your pear shaped engagement ring, not rhodium plating or making sure your center stone isn't loose. That will have to be done on your own dime. 

    Pros

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Free sizing for a year
  • Lifetime upgrade
  • Clear 360 view
  • Cons

    • Not many choices in diamond fine jewelry 
    • Does not cover loss of stones in settings

    #3 Buying Pear Diamonds at Clean Origin

    clean origin homepage

    If you're on a budget and you're not put off by lab diamonds, Clean Origin might just be the option for you. Pear diamond engagement rings at Clean Origin are going to be less expensive than our other retailers. Both James Allen and Ritani also offer lab diamonds as well, but both of them have a small selection of 1 carat pears at minimum. 

    Clean Origin is going to have the best selection of lab diamonds because they only sell lab diamond jewelry. They have around 1700 different pear diamonds to choose from. They also have two different types of viewers for their diamonds and there's no way to filter from each other. 

    I find this a problem because the Diamond Scan view is really crappy compared to their other viewer. The cool thing about the Diamond Scan is you can see the complete underside of the diamond as well, which most 360 viewers don't. But it's not magnified and makes it hard to tell if you're getting an eye clean diamond

    The other viewer has way better magnification and all these fancy little features you don't necessarily need, but at least you can see the dang thing. 

    Clean Origin's return policy really sets them apart from other competitors, even ones that sell comparable lab diamonds. Most places give you 30-60 days to return an item. Clean Origin gives their customers 100 days. My theory is that they're so confident in their quality and customer experience, they want to make sure you are too. 

    The return policy doesn't quite overshadow their lack of a decent warranty though. They have the same warranty as Blue Nile, where they cover manufacturing defects and design flaws, but none of the needed work for your ring.

    Thankfully lab diamonds can be up to 70% cheaper than a mined diamond of the same grades, so you are already saving a lot of money. 

    Read also>> Everything you should know about lab diamonds before you buy

    Pros

    • All lab diamonds
    • 360˚ view
    • carries GIA certified lab diamonds
    • 100 day return policy

    Cons

    • No natural diamonds
    • No warranty

    #4 Buying Pear Diamonds At Ritani

    ritani homepage

    The Ritani name might be recognized in the diamond industry, but not necessarily as an online retailer. Most people know Ritani as a ring setting designer. Some of their ring settings can be purchased at other diamond retailers, like Whiteflash. 

    They don't have a ton of loose pear shape diamonds, with just a little over 100 of our chosen grades. Overall they have around 1100. Ritani's also headed up by the former CEO of Blue Nile, which might also explain why they only carry GIA certified diamonds. 

    Ritani is slowly improving on my biggest issue with them, and that's their viewing for their loose diamonds. It's pretty difficult to find the perfect pear diamond if they don't offer consistent viewing. Some of the diamonds have 360 video, some have HD photos, some have both, and others literally have nothing.

    ritanidiamondviewinginconsistence

    The 360˚ viewer isn't anything to write home about either. It's similar to the Diamond Scan style from Clean Origin, but at least it's magnified up close. But Ritani's video is in a video loop, not controllable. It also spins kind of fast. You'll have to rewind and adjust to check for obvious blemishes or inclusions

    A great feature they have with their diamonds that sets them apart from others in the industry is the Market Analysis. They take the guesswork out of the price by showing how much the vendor is selling your teardrop diamond for, how much of the price goes to shipping and customs, and then Ritani's markup cost. Every diamond at Ritani comes with this analysis. 

    ritani diamond market analysis

    The last thing I want to mention about Ritani because of its rarity is their free lifetime warranty. Other than our top pick James Allen, Ritani is the only other pick that offers a warranty to cover rhodium plating, prong retipping, and tightening stones. You have to sign up online, but that's a far cry to having to pay for one or worse, not being offered it at all.

    Pros

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Free sizing for a year
  • Lifetime upgrade
  • Clear 360 view
  • Cons

    • Not many choices in diamond fine jewelry 
    • Does not cover loss of stones in settings

    Pear Diamonds FAQ

    Here's a list of some of the most popular questions asked about pear or teardrop shape diamonds. 

    Is It Cheaper To Buy Pear Cut Diamonds Online?

    If you're comparing the cost of pear cut diamonds to a place like Kay Jewelers or Zales, you'll find that pear diamonds are much cheaper online. Of course, there's more to the value of a diamond than just its exact numerical price. Certifications and warranties are also big factors in price. 

    You see, it's not just cheaper to buy pears online, but you are going to have way more options. Teardrops are unique shapes, and not all ring wearers want them. Physical jewelry stores can't sink a bunch of money into bringing a range of options for diamond shapes that don't sell as well as a round cut or a princess cut diamond

    So you'll probably only run into a few pear diamonds in-store, like a simple solitaire. Walk into a Kay and ask for a pear shaped diamond and they'll lead you right to the Neil Lane Collection, famous designer of the Bachelor and Bachelorette. 

    Read also>> Should you buy a solitaire setting?

    It's a pretty ring, if you like low quality center stones being sold double what you could actually buy a pave setting pear diamond at James Allen for. Not only that, but you can make sure its not yellow and is eye clean. You can't do that with a Neil Lane ring. 

    The way online diamond retailers do business allows them to sell directly through the vendor. They don't have to pay any kind of premiums to the vendor to keep in their inventory. The vendor ships the diamond to the retailer, they put it together and go through quality check and ship it off to you.

    No hidden fees. It's cheaper for both the online retailer and you! On average, you can save up to 40% by purchasing pear diamonds online instead of at a mega retailer. And that's just off the price itself.

    Are Pear Cut Diamonds More Expensive?

    Round cut diamonds are the most expensive diamond shapes, and all other shapes follow it. Diamond prices are made up of a variety of factors, but the leading cause of higher diamond shapes is how much of the diamond rough is retained during the cutting process. 

    The teardrop and pear shapes are consider the 4th most expensive diamond shape, but can still save you over $1000 than if you would've chosen a round diamond. Round diamond retain very little rough and pear shapes utilize more and the weight is also distributed well. 

    However, pear cut diamonds are difficult to cut well and a less requested shape, so larger carat weight prices will skyrocket. Most large carat pear diamonds are worn by celebrities. 

    Cardi B rocks an 8 carat pear cut diamond engagement ring given to her by Offset that cost $500,000. It features a pink and white diamond halo for a total of 12 carats total. 

    Sophie Turner, famous actress from Game of Thrones, was given a gorgeous 3 carat pear diamond ring from Joe Jonas and it's estimated to be between $30,000-$60,000, though no one knows for sure. 

    Here's where the price of a 1 carat pear cut stone fits in with other shapes

    Pear Diamond Cost

    What Should You Look For When Buying Pear Cut Diamonds?

    Cut

    Cut is always the most important aspect when picking out a diamond of any shape, but it rings especially true for pear or teardrop shape diamonds. You already know that these are unique shapes.

    Since round diamonds are the only shapes that have official cut grades by the GIA, the rest of the fancy shapes have certain guidelines to follow to ensure the best cut quality of that shape. 

    For a pear diamond, the most important factor to pay attention to is the length to width ratio. This decides a great cut from a wonky one. Unfortunately, most pear cuts aren't cut as well as they could be. That severely limits your choices in high quality cut pear diamonds since they only make up around 4% of all diamond shapes cut. 

    You'll find the L/W ratio of the diamond under the diamond details. Places like Kay and Zales won't show you it online. You can find the specifics from any of our retailers when you browse their loose diamonds. 

    The recommended L/W ratio for pear diamonds is between 1.55 and 1.75. Pears outside of these parameters will not have great light performance or even shapes. 

    Symmetry is also extremely important with pears. Most of them are slightly misshapen. Make sure that your polish and symmetry are Excellent. 

    Clarity and Color

    A pear cut diamond is a cross between two brilliant cut diamonds, the round and the marquise. Brilliant cut diamond shapes features lots of short facets all over, giving it a glittering effect. A modern pear diamond has 58 facets, the same as most round diamonds. 

    Because of all the short, choppy facets in the diamond, it makes it harder for obvious inclusions to make themselves known. Brilliant cut diamonds won't need as high of clarity grades as a step cut diamond like an emerald cut or a Asscher cut might need. 

    As long as you've got a good viewer, you can pick out a great SI clarity pear diamond for cheaper. There's no need to buy VVS1 or VVS2 clarity diamonds for pear shapes. 

    Alternately, because the pear retains more rough than other shapes, it shows more color as well. Pears are popular for fancy colored diamonds because more rough is shown. Radiant cut diamonds have this same issue.

    For this reason, I recommend sticking to a G-H color grade range. You don't need a D color, but make sure it's relevant to your setting. Tinted diamonds appear whiter on a yellow gold setting but more tinted on a white gold ring setting. 

    Brilliant cut diamond shapes like the radiant diamond are better hiding more subtle and even some obvious blemishes or inclusions. Step-cut diamonds like the emerald cut or the Asscher cuts reveal obvious inclusions, which is one of the reasons why they're cheaper than brilliant shapes. 

    So when choosing color grades for your radiant, it's not necessary to buy a VVS1 or VVS2 diamond. I usually recommend a VS2 because you'll have more eye clean options, but an SI clarity diamond will save you more money without too much of a difference.

    Just make sure you either go to see it with your naked eye or can see it through a crystal clear viewer to point out any dark inclusions. 

    Diamond color shows more tint in radiant shapes than others. Radiants normally appear larger than other shapes of the same carat weight and they allow jewelers and gemstone cutters to retain more of the diamond rough. The more diamond rough there is, the more color reveals itself. 

    For this reason, radiant cut diamond shapes are very popular for fancy colored diamonds. Many celebrities like Kelly Clarkson, Jennifer Lopez, and Hilary Duff all own colored radiant cut diamond rings. 

    The extra facets in a brilliant cut stone help some, but not as much as we'd like. For a radiant diamond, I'd recommend choosing between the G-H area, unless you prefer warmer diamonds. Some of our readers prefer tinted diamonds that complement their skin tone. 

    Red Flags When Buying Pear Diamonds Online?

    There isn't a lot of red flags with diamond shapes, but there are some things to be aware of. 

    Bowtie and Pointed Shapes

    Pear diamonds have two big things to watch out for: the bowtie and its pointed edges. The bowtie effect is a shadow phenomena that appears on some diamond shapes. Pears, marquise, oval cuts, and radiant cut diamonds are all susceptible to this shadow. 

    Bowties aren't noted on a grading report, so it's important to observe the pear diamond before buying it, whether its online or in-store. Better cut pear diamonds will have less of an effect. 

    A bowtie doesn't compromise the integrity or durability of the diamond, and it's completely up to you how much bowtie you prefer your diamond to have. Some people really like its unique look and others hate it.

    It's completely up to personal preference, but it does inhibit the diamond's brilliance so I feel the need to mention it. 

    As for the pointiness of the diamond, you need to make sure you're choosing a protective ring setting. Pointed shapes like the pear and the marquise cut are more susceptible to chipping. This is the biggest complaint about pear diamonds. Make sure the point is protected. 

    You can protect it by the whole setting, or just the prongs. Most pear cut diamonds have a six prong basket, which ensures the diamond to stay put and protect the edges. Some protective ring settings for pear diamonds might be a be a bezel or halo setting

    Read also>> Should you buy a bezel setting?

    Grading Report

    Throughout this guide, you've heard the words grading report and diamond certification mentioned. The most popular certified diamonds you'll come across are usually by the GIA, AGS, IGI, and GSI. 

    You should always buy a certified diamond as opposed to a non-certified diamond. But not all diamond grading labs grade diamonds the same way. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) created the 4Cs, the system of diamond quality grades. It only makes sense that they would have the most accurate diamond certifications. 

    gia report

    The American Gem Society is the other acceptable grading authority. They grade like the GIA, but their main difference is they grade the AGS Ideal 0 as their Excellent Cut. An Excellent Cut graded diamond from the GIA is the same as an ideal cut diamond, but the GIA just doesn't use that terminology. 

    In short, diamond certifications are a guarantee that a retailer is selling you the right quality diamond for the right price. You'll frequently find "independently certified" or GSI certified diamonds in brick and mortar retailers.

     These retailers use these agencies because they're much cheaper in bulk rather than getting it done at the GIA or AGS. They'll also sell GIA certified diamond engagement rings for more than you'd get them at an online retailer, because it costs the company more. 

    How To Get The Best Deal When Buying Pear Cut Diamonds Online?

    I've touched on a number of different ways and benefits that will help you when buying pear cut diamonds online. Here's a quick recap of Pear Cut Diamonds 101. 

    • Choose a retailer with a clear 360˚ viewer
    • Choose a retailer with enough pears to choose from 
    • Only buy GIA or AGS certified natural diamonds. For lab diamonds, buy GIA, IGI, or GCAL 
    • Choose a retailer with a warranty that covers routine maintenance like retipping prongs or rhodium plating
    • Choose a retailer with a good return policy and easy process
    • Remember that pear cut diamonds are more likely to chip, so protect that pointy tip!
    • Remember that pear cut diamonds hide inclusions more so they don't need the highest clarity grades. 
    • Length to Width ratio is of big importance because most pears aren't cut well.

    Meet Your Jewelry Expert

    Learn More About Jewelry

    Want to learn more about jewelry? Check out these other helpful resources written by our jewelry experts!

    Leave a Comment