Top 5 Best Amethyst Earrings To Buy (2021 Review)

Looking for the best pair of amethyst earrings?

Perfect, you're in the right place!

Earrings can be an especially tricky jewelry purchase.

Any jewelry purchase – especially one that involves the purchase of gemstones – requires an emotional and financial investment that you want to be sure you’ve gotten right.

best amethyst earrings

Add to that the fact that earrings prominently frame your face (as opposed to adorning your wrist or fingers), and it becomes absolutely crucial to make the right choice.

Whether you’ve opted for amethyst because it represents your birth stone, or simply because you adore the beautiful purple hue of this underrated gemstone, we’ve gathered the five best amethyst earrings for you to consider. Let’s jump right in!

Our Overall #1 Rated Pick

Updated On January 15, 2021

  • 14k White Gold
  • Tasteful, discrete settings
  • Rich, deep purple amethysts, that are also eye clean
  • 0.95 carat weight minimum and 5mm diameter means you’re getting a lot of visible gemstone for the money.

Our overall number 1 pick are the beautiful 14K WHITE GOLD AMETHYST BIRTHSTONE EARRINGS from James Allen. At $320 these earrings aren’t necessarily cheap, but they represent a fantastic investment given the quality.

What Are Amethyst Earrings?

Amethyst is a beautiful, purple-colored quartz stone. Until the 18th Century, it was thought to be one of the cardinal stones – those gemstones which are higher value than all others (alongside diamonds, rubies, sapphires and emeralds). However, in the 18th Century large deposits of it were discovered in Brazil, and this diminished much of its market value.

Read Also: What Are Some Of The Top Purple Gemstone Earrings?

What amethyst lacks in scarcity, however, it makes up for in beauty and cultural significance. Unlike the cardinal stones, the value of amethyst does not increase exponentially with carat weight, Instead, its value is determined by the depth or richness of the purple hue it exhibits. The best purple amethyst in the world is Siberian amethyst, which displays approximately 75% purple hue.

In terms of cultural significance, the name amethyst has its roots in ancient Greek meaning ‘not intoxicant’ – as the Greeks believed it would prevent them from becoming drunk! In the middle ages, amethyst was reserved only to royalty, and even today Anglican bishops wear an episcopal set with amethyst (again, alluding to their sobriety). It is also the birthstone for February.

Are Amethyst Earrings Expensive Or Cheap?

The short answer is ‘it depends’. It depends on what you’re comparing them to (diamond earrings, for instance), and it depends on the quality of the amethyst. What I would say though, is that Amethyst is excellent value, given that you’re getting a beautiful semi-precious gemstone. There are few gemstones that can compete with the appearance of rich-purple amethyst, and fewer that can match it for value.

Read Also: What Are The Top Amethyst Necklaces?

When buying amethyst earrings, the price will be determined by two main factors – the material of the setting, and the shade of the amethyst. Sterling silver settings will be quite a bit cheaper than gold, for instance, and rich, deep purple amethyst will cost significantly more than its less saturated counterparts.

What Should You Look For In The Best Amethyst Earrings?

In terms of what you should look for in a good pair of amethyst earrings, the quality will be determined by the setting, and the stone itself.

First and foremost, what is the style of the setting?

Setting Styles

There are countless styles, and they all have their own benefits and drawbacks. Do you prefer stud-type earrings, or something more ornate?

One point to bear in mind is the quality of the stone setting itself – a bezel setting for example is not to everyone’s taste, and will conceal more of the stone, but will do a much better job of protecting the stones should you drop it.

Purple Gemstone Earrings

Setting Material

Next, what is the material of the setting (and how much of it is there)? Again, this will largely come down to personal preference. Some people adore the purple of amethyst against rose gold, others will only wear white gold.

Make sure that what you’re paying is commensurate with the material you’re buying – if you aren’t making a significant saving by opting for silver over platinum, then chances are you’re being swindled.

Quality of Amethyst

Finally, is the quality of the amethyst. Wherever possible, buy earrings that have eye-clean amethyst stones. Whilst an inclusion in the amethyst is unlikely to detract from the beauty of the stone significantly from a distance, it’s likely to bother you from up close.

Hue of Amethyst 

Also, again, the purple hue of the amethyst is where the value is, and you should be aiming to buy the richest, most saturated purple amethyst earrings you can afford.

Also look for amethysts that have a consistent color throughout the stone – many lower-quality stones will display ‘color zones’ where they may have areas of rich purple, but this fades badly in other areas.

As with diamonds, look for well cut amethysts, as this has a significant impact on the appearance of the stones (particularly in low light).

How Do You Clean Amethyst Earrings?

Whilst amethyst is a relatively tough and durable gemstone, there are some key things to keep in mind when cleaning and maintaining it.

Amethyst scores a 7 on the Mohs scale of hardness, meaning it should be fairly safe in jewelry. It’s important to remember that amethyst is a type of quartz. Given that most dust and sand is made up of quartz, this means that it is easy to scratch your earrings if you’re not careful.


It’s for that reason that I recommend gently cleaning your amethyst earrings in warm soapy water. Use a mild dishwashing soap, and allow the earrings to soak for 10-15 minutes, before rinsing clean and drying with a soft cotton cloth.

This method should also be suitable for every precious metal setting. Avoid the use of steam, and avoid ultrasonic cleaners as these can be harmful if the amethyst received manufacturing treatments that you are unaware of.

Where To Buy Amethyst Earrings?

Online if you can!

Specifically, we recommend purchasing your amethyst earrings from James Allen. James Allen is an excellent and reputable jewelry online retailer, who combine the discount prices of a big chain, with the expertise and reliability of a local expert.

We pick online due to the enormous cost savings that come along with buying jewelry online. Not only do you save on costs other retailers need to recoup (rent of building, sales associates, etc), but you get the best possible sales experience because none of the support reps are paid on commission on their site!

Learn more about James Allen by clicking here.

Our Recommended Amethyst Earrings

This is our best value pick. The silver leaf pattern, combined with multiple amethysts in each, offers a very visually appealing pair of earrings.

Add to this the v-prong setting that offers good stone protection (without some of the compromises of bezel settings), and the leverbacks, for added security. The stones have a good cut, and offer a nice shade of purple at this price point.

  • Long enough to dangle, without being so long as to catch
  • Rhodium plating on the silver really adds to the shine
  • Unlikely to find better color amethysts at this price point
  • The stones could benefit from a better cut for improved light performance

Our best of the best selection is a pair of beautiful, deep purple, eye clean amethyst stones with a minimum carat weight of 0.95, that are set in brilliant 14K White Gold settings.

The stones are approximately 5mm in diameter, and this, coupled with the discrete design of the settings, means that they are eye-catching, whilst avoiding being garish.

  • 14K white gold setting
  • Tasteful, discrete design
  • Eye-clean, deep purple amethysts
  • There can be few complaints for this quality of amethysts, at this price

Another nice pair of amethyst stud earrings, these could be viewed as a budget version of our best of the best selection.

Each stud features an amethyst measuring approximately 7mm in diameter, set in a four prong sterling silver setting. The silver setting is not rhodium plated though, and so isn’t as eye-catching as our best budget selection.

  • Good-sized amethysts for the price
  • Nice colour and cut
  • The manufacturer offers a lifetime warranty
  • Some issues reported with the posts on the earrings bending.

Something a little different from our other selections is this lovely pair of cushion cut amethyst earrings, surrounded by lab-created white sapphires. The settings for these earrings are a lovely, ornate, rhodium-plated sterling silver. I have always been a huge fan of cushion cut stones because of how they refract light differently, and these are no exception.

  • Surprisingly good cut of amethyst, given the price point
  • Rhodium plating on the silver adds to the appeal
  • Nice ornate settings
  • The amethyst appears a little unsaturated in certain lights
  • The chunky design wont be to everyone’s taste

It’s hard to go wrong with filigree when purchasing jewelry, and these earrings are no exception. The settings are intricate and detailed, but still have enough presence to be noticed.

What’s more, the settings offer the kind of protection associated with bezels, though unfortunately the enclosed nature of the settings affects how much light can access the amethyst. 

The hue of purple on the stones is also not massively impressive, but that’s to be expected at this price point.

  • Attractive filigree design
  • Setting affords good protection to the amethyst
  • Very well priced
  • The setting detracts somewhat from the light performance of the amethyst
  • The amethyst is not especially saturated

Our Top Pick: 14K White Gold Amethyst Studs

Overall, the 14K white gold amethyst earrings from James Allen are the best purchase. Whilst they are the most expensive, the quality in the color and light performance of the stones is simply leagues beyond the other competitors on the list.

Coupled with tasteful and discrete 14k white gold settings, and they’re everything a pair of amethyst earrings should be.

Meet Your Jewelry Expert

Learn More About Jewelry

Want to learn more about jewelry? Check out these other helpful resources written by our jewelry experts!

Leave a Comment