Top 5 Best Earrings For Sensitive Skin: Hoops & Studs Plus More Facts (2021)

Looking for the best earrings for your sensitive skin?

Perfect, you're in the right place!

In this LearningJewelry.com guide you'll learn:

  • What makes an earring better for sensitive or reactive skin?
  • Why does your skin react in the first place?
  • And what are the best earrings for sensitive skin?
top best Earrings For Sensitive Skin review (2)

Have you ever put in a great pair of earrings, then hastily take them out a few hours later to find your earlobes all swollen and red? Have you ever had a ring turn green on your finger? 

If that's you... 

You probably have a metal sensitivity. The results are the reaction of a metal allergy. 

Here're my top earring picks to help you out.

My Overall #1 Rated Pick

(updated as of 1/8/2020)

My #1 pick for best earrings for sensitive skin is Stud Earrings 24k Gold Plated with  Surgical Steel Posts by Lifetime Jewelry.

Why?

Because although it's a simple and plain design, this pair of earrings are plated with 24K yellow or white gold over surgical grade stainless steel. 

Whether you're a long-time earring wearer, or it's your first ear piercing, these are the perfect pair to get if you're looking to avoid any metal allergies. 

Top 5 Best Earrings For Sensitive Skin

If you're in a hurry, check out my quick list of my top picks. 

Best Earrings For Sensitive Skin Reviewed

Even though our top pick for best earrings for sensitive skin looks plain, there is a method to the madness.

These ball studs are plated in 24 karat gold, which is pure gold. It eliminates the threat of metal allergies like nickel and copper.

Beneath the plating is surgical stainless steel, which is the type of metal a professional body piercer uses for all of their customers.

Medical grade stainless steel is hypoallergenic, so your earring posts will not cause any allergic reactions in the wearer.

These earrings are very simple and straightforward, which makes them versatile as they are perfect for any occasion. Casual or formal, wear as a pair or a singular piercing. They are fitting for either men or women and comes with a lifetime guarantee.

Pros

  • 24 Karat plating
  • Lifetime Guarantee 
  • Versatile
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • Kind of plain

These stylish gold earrings are not pure gold, but they are more likely to be suitable for nickel allergies than 14K or 10K gold earrings.

The price for these is great, especially for a higher karat gold, even if it is plating.

Underneath the plating is sterling silver and these earrings are guaranteed to be nickel-free and lead-free.  

The center stone and halo are made of cubic zirconia, a diamond simulant. 

Pros

  • Nickel-free
  • 18/24 parts pure gold
  • 1 year guarantee

Cons

  • Not hypoallergenic (may be other reactive metals) 
  • CZ scratches over time

This 4 packs of colored stone stud earrings are made of rhodium-finished sterling silver.

Even though sterling silver is mostly hypoallergenic, there are some condition in which it could cause a reaction.

Rhodium puts a layer between your sensitive skin and the sterling silver.

The stones in the pictures are said to be created blue sapphire, black sapphire, green sapphire, and ruby.

However... 

They are simulated as blue spinel, black cubic zirconia, green spinel, and red cubic zirconia. So, if you're looking for genuine stones, you don't want these. But, for under $50, this is a great price. These studs will add a pop of color to your ears and will enhance your wardrobe.

Pros

  • 4 Pack
  • Rhodium 
  • Colorful

Cons

  • More expensive than others on the list
  • Not authentic stones

This 4 pack of stainless steel hoop earrings comes in 4 different sizes. They don't have to be just for your earlobes as either.

You can use them for other piercings too. 

They are also offered in yellow gold, rose gold, and black. However, these are just tones and colors, not actual gold karat. 

The stainless steel in these earrings is medical grade, so it is more hypoallergenic than its regular stainless steel. It has a low nickel amount that shouldn't ignite any reactions.

Pros

  • Multipack
  • Surgical Steel 
  • Multi-use

Cons

  • Colors, not metals
  • May not use all of them

These cubic zirconia stud earrings are plated with 18K gold plating, which makes it more gold than other metal alloy. 

The CZ stones are brilliant-cut, adding more sparkle to your ears.

However...

Cubic zirconia is not suitable for everyday wear as exposure to chlorine and light can cause discoloration. 

The base metal is sterling silver that is nickel-free. Sterling silver is generally hypoallergenic, but is used with other metal alloy and has a small chance of creating a reaction to other metals. 

Pros

  • 18K white or yellow gold
  • Brilliant cut CZ
  • 30 day guarantee

Cons

  • Exposure to other metal allergies 
  • Not suitable for everyday wear

What Kind Of Earrings Are Made For Sensitive Skin?

Nothing is 100% hypoallergenic.

Sterling silver, gold, stainless steel, and titanium earrings all have trace amounts of reactive metals, but they are small amounts and aren't likely to cause issues.

Generally, these only affect those with a highly severe sensitivity. Palladium and niobium are also hypoallergenic, but they aren't commonly purchased. 

The better earrings for sensitive skin are going to be:

  • Pure gold
  • Surgical steel
  • Sterling silver
  • Titanium
  • Palladium and
  • Niobium

Are Earrings Made For Sensitive Skin More Expensive Or Cheap?

You can find a good pair of earrings suitable for sensitive skin for a bargain, especially on Amazon.

However, you will be limited to styles that are adolescent, plated golds, and simulated diamonds or gemstones. 

Read Also: What are the top earrings for newly pierced ears?

If you want natural diamonds or gemstones and solid gold, the price of your earrings are going to go up based on quality factors of those stones.

What Should You Look For In The Best Earrings For Sensitive Skin?

The most common metals that people have when they wear earrings are nickel, zinc, copper, and brass. Some people have stronger reactions than others based on the amount of metal in it. 

Hypoallergenic metal is not the same as nickel-free. Hypoallergenic means free of allergens, which includes all the metal allergies.

If a pair of earrings is nickel-free, they may still contain other metals that could cause a reaction. Nickel is the most common reactive metal which is why you'll find that advertised.

How To Clean Earrings For Sensitive Skin?

Cleaning your earrings generally depends on what they're made of. If they are gold, gold jewelry cleaner will do. If they are sterling silver, you can clean them with silver cleaner.

Read Also: What are my recommended ultrasonic jewelry cleaners?

Be aware that silver cleaner can strip polish and vintage antiquing styles off of sterling silver jewelry. You'll need a polishing cloth to get that shine back. 

Your best bet is using soap and water. For sensitive ears, you should use a soap that is fragrance-free. Brush away any extra dirt with a soft bristled brush.

Where To Buy Earrings For Sensitive Skin?

I generally recommend Amazon for cheap jewelry because they have a ton oof selection and a good refund policy.

Just keep in mind that they are ranked by keywords, so items that aren't necessarily great for sensitive skin will come up, which is why I have this guide to sort through the 1,000's of options for you.

Any of these earrings would make a great choice for the best earrings for sensitive skin.

Choose whichever one fits your style, budget, and hypoallergenic needs.

However, I can't let you leave without a recap of why I think LIFETIME JEWELRY 24K Gold Plated Stud Earrings is the clear winner of the bunch: 

  • 24 karat gold plated- Pure Gold with no other metals
  • Medical grade stainless steel- high quality non-reactive stainless steel
  • Yellow gold or white gold
  • Looks great with multiple earrings
  • Goes with everything
  • Fantastic price

I hope you've enjoyed my pick of the best earrings for sensitive skin. Now, go get yourself some beautiful earrings that will feel good too! 

Have a thought? Let me know in the comments down below!

Meet Your Jewelry Expert

Learn More About Jewelry

Want to learn more about jewelry? Check out these other helpful resources written by our jewelry experts!

Leave a Comment